28 views
The envelope had been placed on top of the morning mail, with my name printed beneath the words DEFENDANT in black capital letters.
I was sorting the electricity bill from a grocery advertisement when my mother pushed it toward me.
“That one needs your attention first,” Elaine said.
I looked at the return address. It was a law office in Henderson. The envelope had been delivered by hand, and someone had written the time of delivery across the upper corner.
“Who brought this?”
“A delivery service.”
“Why is a lawyer sending me something at your house?”
Elaine straightened the napkins beside the fruit bowl. She had already set out two cups of coffee, though she had not touched hers.
“Just open it, Alyssa.”
The yellowed laminate counter still had a small burn mark near the stove. I had made that mark years earlier with a hot baking dish. My mother had complained about it every Thanksgiving since.
I pulled the papers from the envelope.
The first page carried the heading of a civil complaint. Thomas Kincaid and Elaine Kincaid were listed as plaintiffs. My name appeared beneath theirs as the defendant.
I read the names twice.
“You’re suing me?”
Elaine picked up a napkin and folded it into a smaller square.
“Your father believes this is necessary.”
“Necessary for what?”
She did not answer. She moved the folded napkin beside my coffee cup.
I turned to the second page. The complaint accused me of making false claims about my military service and presenting government records that supposedly did not support my account.
There were references to financial damages, public statements, and harm to the family’s reputation.
I stopped at a sentence that described my deployment as unverified.
“Who wrote this?”
“Mr. Sterling,” Elaine said. “Your father has been speaking with him.”
“How long?”
“That isn’t important right now.”
I checked the date on the filing. It had been prepared several days earlier.
My mother had known about it before I arrived that morning. She had also known enough to have the delivery sent to her address instead of mine.
“After everything this family has done,” she began, “we should not have to go through this.”
I put the complaint flat on the counter.
“Then why did you file it?”
Elaine reached for the papers, but I kept one hand on the top page.
“Your father wants an end to the embarrassment.”
I looked toward the small framed family photograph beside the telephone. It showed the three of us before I enlisted. My father had his arm around my mother’s shoulders, and I was standing between them with a smile that showed all my front teeth.
The glass had a fingerprint near the lower corner.
“Does that picture embarrass him too?”
Elaine followed my eyes.
“Don’t start.”
I had not started anything. I had only opened an envelope.
She gathered the remaining mail into a neat pile and moved it away from the complaint.
“Your father is waiting in the dining room.”
I carried the lawsuit with me.
Thomas had spread several documents across the dining table. He was sitting at the end nearest the window, with his reading glasses beside a glass of water.
He moved the family photograph away from the papers before I sat down.
“What’s this?” I asked.
“You’ve read it.”
“I want to hear you explain it.”
He tapped the top sheet with one finger.
“The family has been embarrassed long enough, Alyssa.”
“Which part of my service embarrassed you?”
He adjusted the papers until their edges lined up.
“This isn’t about one particular incident.”
“Then why does the complaint say I fabricated my deployment?”
“Because there are questions about your records.”
“Which records?”
Thomas picked up a page and passed it across the table. It was a prepared statement, typed and dated two days earlier.
The statement said that he and Elaine had no reliable knowledge of my deployment and believed my military claims had been exaggerated.
I read the paragraph at the bottom.
It was written in the first person, as though my father were describing something he had personally investigated.
“Did you sign this?”
“Not yet.”
“Did you write it?”
“Mr. Sterling prepared the wording.”
I placed the statement beside the complaint.
“You have already decided what happened before asking me for anything.”
Thomas leaned back.
“We have asked you plenty of times.”
“When?”
He looked toward the kitchen.
“Your mother has tried to discuss this with you.”
“My mother has asked me not to mention Kandahar at family dinners.”
“That is not the same thing.”
“No, it isn’t.”
He lifted the family photograph and placed it on the sideboard, facing away from the table.
I watched him do it.
“Why move that?”
“Because we need room.”
There was enough room for the photograph. There was also enough room for the water glass, the complaint, and the statement.
I picked up the statement again.
It contained no dates, no unit information, and no reference to the military documents Thomas claimed were unreliable.
“Have you looked at my discharge paperwork?”
“I have seen enough.”
“That’s not an answer.”
He folded his hands.
“You need to understand that this has gone beyond a disagreement between a father and daughter.”
“You’re the one who filed a lawsuit.”
“We are trying to protect ourselves.”
“From what?”
He reached for his water and took a drink.
“From further embarrassment.”
The word appeared again, but he still had not told me what I had supposedly done.
I put the papers into my folder and stood.
Thomas did not ask me to stay.
My old bedroom was still being used for storage, but the desk remained beneath the window. A stack of folded blankets sat on the chair, and the bottom drawer stuck whenever I pulled it open.
I moved the blankets and took out my blue deployment notebook.
Its cover had softened along the edges. I had kept it protected from water and dust, even when other papers from that period had been moved several times.
I placed my discharge paperwork beside it.
The dates matched.
I checked the service period, the unit information, and the entries I had written while deployed. There was nothing uncertain about the dates in my own records.
The notebook was not a diary. I had written down names, assignments, dates, and short notes because that was what I needed to do at the time.
Some pages were crowded. Others had only a few lines.
I opened to the section marked with a small blue tab.
A date had been written in the upper corner. Beneath it were the names of the medical personnel assigned to our unit.
I ran my finger down the list.
One name had been written in smaller letters than the others.
I closed the cover when I heard footsteps in the hallway.
Thomas appeared in the doorway.
“What are you doing with that?”
“Checking my records.”
He looked at the notebook rather than at me.
“Put it away.”
“It’s mine.”
“I know whose it is.”
“Then why are you asking?”
He stepped into the room and moved a folded blanket from the desk.
“You need to stop discussing Kandahar.”
I kept one hand on the notebook.
“Why?”
“Because it is making this worse.”
“For whom?”
He glanced at the paperwork beside me.
“Those notes are not going to help you.”
“You haven’t read them.”
“I don’t need to.”
That answer stayed between us for a few seconds.
I opened the notebook again.
Thomas looked toward the page, then turned his attention to the discharge paperwork.
“Give me the original.”
“No.”
“Your mother and I are trying to keep this matter contained.”
“Contained from whom?”
He rubbed the edge of the desk with his thumb.
“You’re making a mistake by holding on to documents that can be misunderstood.”
I slid the notebook closer to me.
“These are my records.”
He took a step back.
“Think carefully before you make this public.”
I looked at the complaint in my folder.
“You already made it public.”
Thomas left the doorway without another word.
I checked the notebook’s cover, closed it, and placed it inside my work bag.
There was a small pocket inside where I kept documents I did not want folded or damaged. The notebook fitted there without bending.
I zipped the pocket shut.
On the desk, the discharge paperwork remained open to the page showing my service dates.
I put that away too.
A little after ten, Elaine came upstairs carrying a cardboard box.
She set it on the bed and began removing old photographs.
“These belong to you,” she said.
I was checking the zipper on my work bag.
“Why are you giving them to me now?”
“Your father doesn’t want personal family items mixed up with the legal papers.”
“Which legal papers?”
She ignored the question and lifted a photograph of me standing beside a birthday cake. The candles had been arranged in two uneven rows, and one had fallen sideways into the frosting.
“You always wanted the first piece,” she said.
“I was usually the one who cut the cake.”
“You cut it badly.”
I almost smiled.
“Nobody complained when they got the biggest piece.”
For a few seconds, we were discussing a cake rather than a lawsuit.
Then Elaine put the photograph into the box.
“Take these with you before this becomes public.”
I looked at her.
“What exactly do you think is going to become public?”
She straightened a stack of pictures.
“The complaint, the arguments, all of it. People don’t need to know about private family matters.”
“You filed the complaint.”
“Your father made that decision.”
“And you signed it.”
She stopped sorting.
“After everything this family has done, I am not going to stand by while our name is dragged through the neighborhood.”
I picked up the birthday photograph and put it back in the box.
“Then you should have asked me what happened before signing something that says I lied.”
Elaine closed the box flaps.
She carried it downstairs, and I followed her toward the front porch.
The morning had become a series of small tasks. Each time I asked a question, my mother found another paper to straighten or another object to move.
She placed the cardboard box near the porch railing.
“Take it today.”
“I’ll take it.”
“And don’t leave anything else here.”
I looked at her.
“Are you asking me to move out?”
“You don’t live here, Alyssa.”
“I know where I live.”
“Then there should be no problem.”
She went back inside and returned with a smaller bundle of photographs.
I began checking the pictures before putting them in my car. There were school photographs, birthday pictures, and several old snapshots from family trips.
Near the bottom of the box, I found a brown envelope.
It was tucked between two cardboard-backed frames, separate from the loose photographs.
I lifted it carefully.
My mother’s hand moved toward it.
“That one can stay here.”
I looked at the envelope.
“Why?”
“It’s old paperwork.”
“It has photographs inside.”
“Then they’re probably family pictures.”
I turned it over. There was no name on the front, only a small handwritten date in one corner.
The paper had been handled enough that the flap no longer lay flat.
I had seen the handwriting before, but not recently.
“Have you opened this?”
