113 views
The tarnished button rang against the bottom of the Mason jar,
and Birdie screwed the lid down as if it might get away from her.
“Edgar left it on the rail,” she said. “Right where the peanuts go. He’s trading.”
I swept the empty shells into the dustpan in short strokes.
Four dollars and twenty-nine cents a bag at the hardware store on Main,
and the second bag was already half gone.
Birdie held the jar up to the window light.
The pearl earring slid past the bottle cap and settled next to the button,
and her pink plastic butterfly clip caught the sun above her left ear.
“Trade means he gives us something and we give him something,”
she said. “So he keeps the peanuts fair and square.”
“Fair and square,” I said. “Put it on the shelf before you drop it.”
A shadow crossed the screen. Walter Dennison came up
the flagstone path with his clipboard under one arm
and his good shoes on, and he stopped at
the bottom step like a man who had practiced the distance.
“Mrs. Vines,” he said. Then, “Vance. Afternoon.”
I set the dustpan on the porch table and pressed
my thumb against the wedding band on my left hand. “Mr. Dennison.”
“Bylaw 14 prohibits attracting scavenger birds to residential lots,
Ms. Vance, and your grace period expired three weeks ago.”
He tapped the gold-nibbed fountain pen twice against
the clipboard and held out a yellow slip. “Seventy-five dollars.”
The paper was still warm from his jacket pocket.
“Seventy-five dollars for peanuts.”
“For the birds the peanuts attract.” He glanced past me,
at the back gate, at the brush line behind the yard.
“Every safety grate in this subdivision was inspected and locked in April,
so don’t go telling folks the association lets things run wild.”
Under the notice, clipped with a wire paperclip, was a yellow carbon copy
of a complaint form. The bottom line for a signature was empty.
The date at the top read March 4.
“Who filed this?”
“It came through the office.”
“There’s no name on it.”
Walter tapped the pen once. “It came through the office, Ms. Vance. Seventy-five dollars, thirty days.”
I turned the carbon over. Nothing on the back but the ghost of writing pressed through from the sheet that had lain above it, wide loops, dark ink, a hand I could not put a name to.
“I bought the first bag of peanuts on April 11,” I said. “The receipt is on my refrigerator.”
“Then bring it Tuesday night.” He was already backing down the path. “Board forum, seven o’clock.”
Birdie came out from behind my elbow with the jar hugged to her chest. “Is Edgar in trouble?”
Walter looked at her the way a man looks at a bill he does not remember agreeing to. “The bird is not in trouble, sweetheart. The bird is the problem.”
He was at the corner of the house before I could ask him what the difference was.
I put the notice under the sugar bowl with the rest of the bills and stood at the screen a minute, looking at the yard.
At five I took Birdie out the back door to look at the brush line. I wanted to see what Walter had been looking at.
The cedar gate stuck. I lifted it with my hip and it swung out over the grass, and the whole alley of blackberry and sumac opened up behind the yard, going down toward the water.
“Edgar lives down there,” Birdie said. “Past the fence.”
“Edgar lives in the oak tree.”
“He lives in the oak tree and he visits down there.” She twisted the butterfly clip above her ear. “Those are two different addresses.”
A calico kitten came out from under the bottom rail of the gate, small enough to fit in a coffee cup, one ear folded down.
“Mom.”
“I see it.”
The kitten walked three steps, sat, and washed its face as though we were the ones intruding.
Birdie crouched and put out her hand. The kitten bolted, not toward the house but along the fence line toward the gully, and it went down through the weeds faster than a kitten ought to be able to go.
Edgar cawed twice from the fence post. Two flat notes, and then nothing.
“He’s saying it’s all right,” Birdie said.
“He’s saying something.” I pulled the gate shut and dropped the latch, and it caught on the second try. “Come on. Homework.”
After supper I spread the bills across the kitchen table with Birdie’s homework notebook at my elbow, open to a page of numbered sentences about a cat.
Mortgage, due the first. Water, paid. Electric, paid. Property tax, second installment, one hundred and forty-one days past the county’s patience.
Four hundred and six dollars in the household account until Friday’s transcription check cleared. I wrote the number on the corner of an envelope, then wrote seventy-five under it, then three hundred and thirty-one.
Birdie erased a word so hard the paper went gray. “Mom, what’s a scavenger?”
“A bird that eats what it finds.”
“So a scavenger is a bird that shares.”
“That’s one way to look at it.”
“Is Edgar a scavenger?”
“Yes.”
“Then he isn’t doing anything wrong.” She turned the notebook around to show me. Under the cat sentence she had drawn a crow with a bottle cap in its beak.
I pressed my thumb against the wedding band and did not say anything.
Birdie went up at eight. I washed the plates and set the jar back on the windowsill where she likes it, next to the empty bowl.
Then I sat down at the table with the yellow carbon copy under the lamp.
March 4. Nobody in this house had fed a bird in March. The peanuts came home on April 11 in a paper sack, and the receipt was still on the refrigerator under a magnet shaped like Ohio.
Somebody had written a complaint about a bird that had not been fed yet, and Walter Dennison had handed me the fine with a straight face and his good shoes on.
Walter had also said every grate in the subdivision was inspected and locked in April. Last week I drove County Road 14 past the embankment and saw the big concrete mouth of that culvert bare, water running out of it into the weeds.
I folded the carbon copy into the manila folder with the tax notice and set my alarm for six.
The porch was dark past the screen. Edgar sat on the rail with his head turned toward the house, not moving, not calling.
I switched off the kitchen light so I could see him better, and he stayed.
Walter’s pen rolled toward the edge of the clipboard, and he caught it before it fell.
I slipped the yellow carbon copy into my handbag.
At 8:45 Tuesday morning, he was sorting envelopes behind the clubhouse office desk. Three piles sat beside his coffee cup, each held down by a small brass paperweight.
“Mr. Dennison, I need a copy of the March 4 complaint.”
He kept sorting.
“Good morning to you, too, Clara.”
“Good morning. I would like a copy of the complaint that led to Monday’s notice.”
Walter placed an envelope in the outgoing pile and picked up another.
“Those records are association business.”
“My fine is association business. I believe I am entitled to see what I am being accused of.”
He looked over his glasses.
“Bylaw 14 is quite clear. You have been attracting scavenger birds to your property.”
“I understand the bylaw. I am asking who made the complaint.”
Walter tapped his gold-nibbed fountain pen twice against his clipboard.
“Why are you so interested in March 4?”
“Because I did not start feeding Edgar until April.”
He took a sip of coffee. A brown ring had formed around the bottom of the cup.
“Perhaps you were attracting him before you started putting out peanuts.”
“With what?”
“Birds find food in all sorts of places.”
I waited for him to open the filing cabinet behind his desk. He had mentioned the complaint was on file, and I could see the cabinet’s top drawer had a label marked VIOLATIONS.
He did not move toward it.
“Could you please get the folder?”
“That cabinet contains confidential correspondence.”
“Then you can make a copy without giving me the original.”
Walter pushed the outgoing mail into a neat stack.
“Clara, I have already spent too much time on this matter.”
“Five minutes would be enough.”
He glanced at the wall calendar. A red circle had been drawn around Friday’s date.
“Your fine increases to three hundred dollars on Friday. I would suggest you put your attention toward paying it instead of looking for arguments.”
“Three hundred dollars?”
“That is the repeat-offender schedule.”
“I have never received a first notice before Monday.”
He lifted his coffee again but did not drink.
“Your grace period expired three weeks ago.”
I looked at the filing cabinet. The bottom drawer was slightly open, but the top one remained locked.
“Then show me the March 4 complaint.”
“No.”
It was such a plain answer that I almost asked him to repeat it.
Instead, I picked up the library flyer lying beside his mail. It advertised a used-book sale at the clubhouse the following Saturday.
“Will the office be open later?”
“Office hours are posted on the door.”
“I can read a schedule, Walter.”
His mouth tightened.
“Then I trust we understand each other.”
I left without another word, but I had not forgotten the filing cabinet.
At 9:30, Teresa Miller was standing in the clubhouse hallway with a stack of library flyers against her chest. She had a peppermint wrapper folded into a tiny square between her fingers.
“Clara, there you are.”
She spoke loudly enough for anyone in the office to hear.
“I was hoping to give Walter these flyers for the Saturday book sale.”
She held out the stack. Beneath it lay a small brass key.
I looked at her hand.
“Is that what I think it is?”
“Keep your voice down.”
She passed me the flyers, and the key slipped into my palm.
“I had this from when I served as association secretary. Three years ago, they gave me a spare for the supply closet.”
“Does it still work?”
“It did the last time I used it.”
“Teresa, I cannot get you into trouble.”
She adjusted the flyers against her blouse.
“Then do not tell anyone where you got it.”
I closed my fingers around the key.
“Why are you helping me?”
She glanced toward Walter’s office.
“Because I have watched that man turn a simple question into a neighborhood offense.”
A chair scraped inside the office.
Teresa raised her voice again.
“Be sure to tell the children the book sale starts at ten!”
Then she walked toward the front entrance.
I waited until Walter’s office door closed before turning toward the supply closet.
The key fit.
Inside, shelves held folding chairs, old holiday decorations, boxes of printer paper, and several binders with faded labels. A small ceiling bulb flickered when I pulled the door shut.
The maintenance binder was on the second shelf.
I set the flyers on a cardboard box and opened it.
The first section contained invoices for lawn care and clubhouse repairs. Behind those were inspection records arranged by month.
I found April.
The page was headed COUNTY ROAD 14 DRAINAGE EASEMENT INSPECTION.
Walter’s signature appeared at the bottom.
I read the entry twice.
Steel grate present, secured with locking bolts. Inspection completed. No deficiencies reported.
The date was April 18.
I took out my phone.
The first photograph showed the entire page. The second showed Walter’s signature. I took a third of the paragraph describing the grate and its locking bolts.
Then I turned to the page behind it.
There was an invoice number written in blue ink, but no invoice attached.
I checked the next section. It contained receipts for clubhouse maintenance, landscaping, and parking lot work.
One line had been crossed through in pencil.
I leaned closer.
The words were difficult to make out, but the amount beside them was clear.
$2,400.
I photographed that page, too.
A door closed somewhere in the clubhouse.
I stopped moving.
Footsteps crossed the hallway, then stopped outside the supply closet.
“Hello?”
It was Walter.
I held the binder open with one hand and kept my phone low beside my leg.
“Teresa? Did you leave the flyers?”
The handle moved once.
I waited.
He walked away, calling someone on his phone.
I returned the binder to the shelf, making sure the April section was in its original place. The key went into my coat pocket.
When I stepped into the hallway, the office door was open.
Walter was speaking to someone I could not see.
“Every safety grate in this subdivision was inspected and locked in April, so stop looking for excuses to excuse your bird.”
He looked up as I passed.
I gave him a small nod.
He did not ask what I had been doing.
By 11:15, Teresa and I stood beside the County Road 14 embankment with our shoes pressed into the damp ground.
I had brought the photographs on my phone. Teresa had brought a pair of old gardening gloves and a small notebook.
“Are you sure this is the right place?” she asked.
I showed her the picture of the inspection sheet.
She read the heading and looked down the slope.
“It says the grate was secured.”
“That’s what I read.”
“Then let’s see it.”
The blackberry brambles covered much of the embankment. Teresa pushed a branch aside with her gloved hand while I stepped around a patch of loose stones.
“Watch your footing,” she said.
“I am.”
“That is what people say just before they fall.”
I gave her a look.
She smiled briefly.
“My husband used to say the same thing when I went into his garden.”
We moved farther down.
The gully was steeper than it appeared from County Road 14. A narrow stream ran along the bottom, carrying leaves and small pieces of bark toward the drainage opening.
Then I saw the concrete.
The culvert mouth was enormous. Its circular opening stood beneath the road, surrounded by dark stains and tangled weeds.
There was no grate.
I stopped beside Teresa.
“Look at that.”
She moved closer, holding a branch away from her face.
“Where are the locking bolts?”
I pointed toward the concrete rim.
There were four empty holes around the opening.
Teresa crouched and examined them.
“Someone took the whole thing off.”
I looked into the pipe.
It was fifty-four inches high, with a flat concrete floor and sixty feet of darkness beneath the road. A thin stream of water crossed the bottom.
“Could the grate have been removed for repairs?” Teresa asked.
“Maybe.”
“Wouldn’t there be a notice?”
“I don’t know.”
She looked toward the weeds beside the embankment.
“Clara, what is that?”
A rusted steel grate lay partly buried in the grass. One corner was caught beneath a blackberry vine.
I walked over and pulled the vine aside.
The grate was heavy, with several bars bent slightly out of line. Its edges were covered in rust, and there were no bolts attached to it.
Teresa stood over it.
“That cannot be what they mean by inspected and locked.”
“No.”
“Could somebody have taken it off after April?”
I examined the weeds beneath it. Dry leaves had collected around the frame, and a thin branch had grown through one of its openings.
I could not tell how long it had been there.
But the April inspection sheet had claimed something very different.
I took another photograph.
Teresa opened her notebook and wrote down the date printed on the ledger.
“April 18,” she said.
“Yes.”
“And you saw this opening last week?”
“I drove past it on Thursday.”
“Was the grate here then?”
“I never noticed the one in the weeds.”
She looked from the loose steel frame to the bare concrete opening.
“That is not the same as being locked.”
A small movement caught my attention inside the pipe.
I raised my phone, but whatever had moved was already gone.
“Did you see that?” I asked.
Teresa leaned forward.
“What?”
“Something near the bottom.”
She looked into the opening.
“Water, perhaps.”
I waited for another movement.
Nothing came.
Teresa stepped back from the edge.
“Clara, I think we should tell the county.”
“I agree.”
“Not Walter?”
I looked at the rusted grate.
“He signed the inspection.”
Teresa closed her notebook.
“That is exactly why I would rather speak to someone outside the association.”
I took out my phone and opened the April photograph again.
The words were clear.
Steel grate present, secured with locking bolts.
Walter’s signature sat directly beneath them.
I enlarged the picture until the signature filled the screen. The ink was dark and even, with a long final stroke beneath his surname.
There was no question about whose name was written there.
I lowered the phone and looked toward the road.
A car passed above us, its tires making a brief rushing sound across the pavement.
“Do you suppose the county knows?” Teresa asked.
“I don’t know.”
“Someone must have checked this before.”
I looked back at the pipe.
“Someone signed that they did.”
She did not answer.
I opened the camera again and stepped closer to the embankment. The raw concrete mouth filled the screen, and I moved the phone slowly from one side to the other.
Water trickled across its floor.
Then I zoomed in.
I saved the photograph before the water on the concrete floor could blur the details. Teresa had told me to bring the complaint copy next door, and I put it between two sheets of paper so the yellow carbon would not tear.
At 1:20, Teresa had two glasses of iced tea waiting on her kitchen table. She moved a stack of library books to make room for the papers.
“Put the March 4 copy beside Walter’s clubhouse notices,” she said. “Not on top. I want to see both at once.”
She had kept several old association memos from her time as secretary. The papers were held together with a faded blue rubber band, and she removed it carefully.
“These are from the year he became president,” she said. “He was already writing complaints about people leaving garden hoses out.”
I placed the yellow complaint beside a memo about a broken clubhouse window. The handwriting looked ordinary enough until Teresa brought her glasses closer.
She pointed to the capital W in Walter’s signature. The first stroke dipped below the line, then came back up in a narrow loop.
“Look at that,” she said.
I leaned over the table.
“That could belong to somebody else.”
“Could it?”
Teresa laid a third paper beside the first two. It was a note Walter had written about replacing the clubhouse mailbox lock.
The same W appeared again. So did the small hook at the end of the letter n, and the way the writer pressed harder on the downstrokes.
Teresa took the complaint and held it near the kitchen window.
“Clara, he wrote this himself.”
I looked at the date. March 4. The complaint claimed I had been attracting crows to my yard and disturbing the neighborhood.
“I did not even have peanuts then,” I said.
“I know.”
“I bought the first bag in April.”
Teresa tapped the two matching letters with one fingernail.
“And look at the ink. That gold pen of his leaves a little darker line whenever he stops and starts again.”
I remembered the two taps of that pen against his clipboard. I remembered the way he had handed me the notice without looking at Birdie.
“Can you prove it was his pen?”
“Not in a courtroom, dear. But I can show you three examples, and I can tell you who had access to the complaint book.”
She opened another folder. Inside were copies of meeting notices, repair requests, and a handwritten list of homeowners who had complained about clubhouse expenses.
“Why keep all this?” I asked.
“Because Walter never throws away a paper that might make him look important.”
She smiled briefly, then stopped when she reached the bottom of the folder.
There was a blank line on the old secretary’s inventory marked March 4, nuisance complaint, original filed.
“Where is the original?” I asked.
Teresa turned the page over.
“That is what I would like to find out.”
She handed me the carbon copy. I photographed the matching handwriting beside Walter’s clubhouse memo, making sure the dates showed in both pictures.
“Keep those somewhere he cannot get to them,” she said.
“I have already photographed the culvert.”
Teresa lowered her voice.
“Then you have more than a bird complaint now.”
I folded the papers into my purse. Before I left, Teresa put a small packet of peppermint candies beside my keys.
“Take these for Birdie. She likes the red wrappers.”
I thanked her, though I knew Birdie would probably spend more time folding the wrappers than eating the sweets.
At 3:40, I was standing with two neighbors at the Sycamore Lane mailboxes. I had brought the envelopes from our box and was sorting them while the others collected their own mail.
Mrs. Harlan from the corner house was pulling advertisements from her mailbox when I asked her a question.
“Did you sign a complaint about Edgar?”
She looked at the envelope in her hand.
“Who told you about that?”
“I am asking whether you signed it.”
“No, Clara. I didn’t sign anything.”
Mr. Pritchard had been listening from the next mailbox. He closed his little metal door and stepped away from me.
“Walter said the crow was spreading disease,” he said.
“Which disease?”
He looked at Mrs. Harlan.
“I don’t know. He said the bird was carrying it from the woods.”
“Did he tell you that a wildlife complaint had been filed?”
“He said several people were concerned.”
Mrs. Harlan put her mail under her arm.
“I thought the association was handling it. I did not want to get involved.”
“Did either of you see the complaint?”
Neither answered.
I took the yellow copy from my purse, keeping Teresa’s handwriting comparison tucked behind it.
“This was dated March 4. I did not buy peanuts until April. I am trying to find out who complained before there was anything to complain about.”
Mr. Pritchard glanced at the date.
“Maybe Walter had information you don’t have.”
“What information?”
He pushed his mailbox shut.
“Ask him. I don’t want trouble with the association.”
Mrs. Harlan moved closer to her car.
“He told us the crow had been coming around your daughter. He said children should not be near wild birds.”
“Did he say anything about the drainage gully?”
She shook her head.
“Why would he?”
I had no answer that I could give them without showing the photographs. They were already looking past me toward their houses.
Mr. Pritchard cleared his throat.
“We have all lived here a long time, Clara. Nobody wants the neighborhood turning into a mess.”
I picked up my envelopes.
“Neither do I.”
He nodded, but he did not look at me again.
When I reached my townhouse, I put the two photographs of Walter’s handwriting into a separate folder on my computer. I named it March 4. The culvert photographs remained in another folder.
I had two records now, and neither one explained why Walter was so anxious to keep me quiet.
At 4:30, Birdie was on the screened back porch with her glass Mason jar beside her. She had taken out the bottle cap, the silver button, and the pearl earring, then arranged them in a row on a folded paper towel.
“Edgar gets four today,” she told me.
I was kneeling beside the back cedar gate with a small screwdriver, trying to make the latch catch properly.
“Four peanuts?”
“Four shelled ones. He can eat them faster.”
“That is considerate.”
Birdie counted them carefully before setting them on the porch railing.
“One, two, three, four.”
I tightened the loose screw and tested the latch. It caught once, then slipped free when I pushed the gate from the other side.
“That is not good,” I said.
“Is it broken?”
“Not completely. It needs another turn.”
Birdie watched me work.
“Does Edgar know that the gate is supposed to stay shut?”
“I don’t think he understands gates.”
“Then somebody should explain.”
I looked over at her.
“Perhaps you could explain it to him.”
She considered that.
“He might understand if I use his name first.”
A crow landed on the fence post. Birdie straightened and lifted one hand.
“Hello, Edgar. Those are yours. Please don’t take all four in one bite.”
The bird hopped toward the peanuts.
Birdie smiled and moved her jar closer to the porch wall.
I turned the screwdriver again. The screw held this time, and I pulled the gate toward me to test it.
Before I could close it, something moved beneath the bottom rail.
A small calico kitten slipped through the gap.
It stopped just inside the yard, looked toward Birdie, and then hurried across the grass.
“Kitty!” Birdie called.
The kitten did not come closer. It passed the porch steps and headed toward the brush behind the fence.
“Wait,” I said.
I set the screwdriver down and went after it.
The kitten disappeared between two low branches. A moment later, I saw its tail flick near the edge of the gully.
“Mom, it came back.”
Birdie was standing beside the gate.
“Stay on the porch, sweetheart.”
“But it might be hungry.”
“I’ll see where it went.”
The kitten appeared again for just a second. Its coat was muddy around the paws, but the rest of it looked dry.
It slipped beneath the brush and vanished.
I walked to the fence line, but the ground beyond it fell away too sharply for me to follow without proper shoes.
“Does it live down there?” Birdie asked.
“I don’t know.”
“Then where does it sleep?”
I looked toward the gully. The branches hid most of the slope.
“I will have to find out.”
Birdie picked up the four peanuts and returned them to the little dish.
“Maybe Edgar knows.”
The crow had taken two peanuts and was working on a third.
“Edgar knows where the good food is,” I said.
“That isn’t the same thing.”
She was right, but I had no answer.
I went back to the gate and tested the latch again. It caught firmly this time. Still, I could not stop looking at the narrow space beneath the bottom rail.
At 6:05, someone knocked on the front door.
Birdie was in the living room, putting her shiny gifts back into the Mason jar. I opened the door and found Walter Dennison holding a red-bordered sheet of paper.
“Good evening, Ms. Vance.”
He did not wait for me to invite him inside.
“I have another association notice for you.”
I kept one hand on the door.
“What now?”
He held up the paper. The number 300 was printed in large black figures near the top.
“Repeat wildlife violation. Three hundred dollars.”
I looked at the date and then at the paragraph beneath the amount.
“This says I continued feeding a nuisance bird after receiving the first notice.”
“That is correct.”
“You know I stopped putting food out?”
“I am not here to debate your feeding habits.”
Behind me, Birdie came to the hallway. She had the jar held against her stomach.
Walter noticed her and lowered his voice.
“Good evening, young lady.”
Birdie did not answer.
I moved slightly so she was behind me.
“Who signed this?”
“The association issued it.”
“That wasn’t my question.”
Walter produced his fountain pen and tapped it twice against the paper.
“The board has procedures, Clara. You received a warning. You ignored it. The fine has now increased.”
“I did not receive a warning in March.”
He looked at me for a moment.
“The original complaint was entered into the records on March 4.”
“I know the date.”
“Then you know the association has been patient.”
I pressed my thumb against my wedding band.
“Nobody complained to me in March. Nobody saw me feeding Edgar in March. I had not even bought the peanuts.”
Walter folded the corner of the notice between his fingers.
“You are making this unnecessarily difficult.”
“Why is the association so concerned about one crow?”
His eyes moved briefly toward the hallway, where Birdie was still holding her jar.
“Because the rules apply to everyone, Clara.”
I took the paper from him.
The notice stated that payment was due by Friday at 5:00 PM. Beneath that, in smaller print, it warned that the association attorney could file a lien against my townhouse if the amount remained unpaid.
“Three hundred dollars,” I said.
“Correct.”
“By Friday at five.”
“Correct.”
“And if I don’t pay?”
Walter straightened his tie.
“Three hundred dollars by Friday at five, or the association attorney files the lien at the county recorder’s desk.”
I looked down at the notice again.
“Does this mean I cannot speak at the board forum?”
He seemed pleased that I had asked.
“On the contrary. You are expected to attend the evening meeting. You may present your concerns in the proper manner.”
“My concerns about the crow?”
“Your concerns about the violation.”
I almost asked him whether the board had a proper manner for inspecting an open drainage pipe. Instead, I kept my mouth closed.
He had not seen my photographs. He did not know Teresa had compared the complaint with his old memos.
“Will you be attending?” I asked.
“I am the association president.”
“Then I expect you will be there.”
“Of course.”
He glanced past me once more.
“Birdie should understand that wild animals are not playthings.”
Birdie stepped forward just enough for her voice to reach the door.
“Edgar isn’t a plaything. He brings presents.”
Walter looked at her.
“Those presents are probably rubbish, sweetheart.”
“They aren’t rubbish. One is a pearl.”
He gave a thin smile.
“Well, I am sure your mother can explain the difference.”
I closed the door before I answered him.
For a few seconds, Birdie and I stood in the hallway. She held the jar up so I could see the little objects inside.
“Is three hundred dollars a lot, Mom?”
“It is more than I have set aside for this.”
“Can we ask Edgar to bring three hundred dollars?”
I looked at her serious little face.
“No, sweetheart. He doesn’t have pockets.”
She laughed, and I put the notice on the hall table.
Then I went to my desk and opened the property tax envelope. The next installment was still waiting, and the money I had kept for it would not cover both payments.
I took out my calculator.
Seventy-five dollars had already been difficult. Three hundred would mean choosing which bill to leave unpaid.
Birdie came over and placed her jar beside my keyboard.
“Can I put the silver button back now?”
“Of course.”
She dropped it in gently.
I picked up Walter’s notice and read the final paragraph again. The lien warning was printed in red, with Friday’s date directly beneath it.
Then I opened the folder containing the culvert photographs.
The concrete opening was still there, exactly as I had photographed it. The rusted grate was still lying in the weeds. Walter’s signature on the April inspection sheet still claimed the pipe had been secured.
I printed the photograph showing the bare entrance and put it beside the new notice.
A man could write a great many rules about a backyard bird. He could not make an open drainage pipe disappear by writing that it had a locked grate.
I heard Birdie talking to Edgar outside. The crow answered from the fence.
I put the tax envelope back in its drawer and carried the notice to the front door.
The red border caught the light as I lifted it from the paper beneath.
Friday at five.
I had three days to find out why Walter was so determined to keep me from looking beyond my own fence.
The clubhouse door had not finished swinging shut behind me before Walter Dennison brought his gavel down on the oak table.
“Mrs. Vance. You are not on the agenda.”
I set the eight-by-ten photographs in a row on the table anyway, one after the other, the way I set out bills when the numbers had to be faced. Twenty homeowners turned in their folding chairs.
“These were taken this morning at the County Road 14 embankment,” I said. “The pipe is fifty-four inches high and sixty feet long and there is no grate on it. The steel grate is lying in the weeds, unbolted.”
Walter did not look down at the pictures. “Bylaw nine, section four. Only board-approved items may be presented during open forum.”
“Then approve it. It will take one minute.”
Someone laughed near the coffee urn. Walter tapped his gold-nibbed pen twice against his clipboard.
“The chair calls Mrs. Vance out of order.”
I stayed where I was. The photographs showed what they showed. A dark concrete mouth, a rusted grate in the briars, water running shallow across the pipe floor. Anybody in that room could have walked down and looked for themselves.
“Mrs. Vance has had a difficult two years,” Walter said, and his voice went gentle in a way I had not heard from him before. “We all know it.”
The room quieted the way rooms do when a man is about to be kind at somebody else’s expense.
He picked up a folded page from his clipboard and opened it. I recognized the newsprint before he read a word, the same half column I had kept in the bottom of my jewelry box.
“Clara Anne Vance, survived by her husband, Daniel Edward Vance, taken too soon at forty-one.” He let the page settle flat. “A man of great patience and good humor.”
Nobody moved. The furnace kicked on and pushed warm air through the floor vents.
“We all sympathize with how quiet a house gets after a loss, Clara, but turning a wild scavenger into a pet is not the answer. First it is peanuts on the railing, and then it is imaginary hazards in the drainage easement, and now it is photographs.”
“I am not imagining a missing grate. It is lying in the weeds.”
“Seconded motion to proceed to new business,” said the man near the urn, and the vote went through with eleven hands and not one of them looked at me.
Teresa Miller had her peppermint wrapper folded into a triangle the size of her thumbnail. She did not raise her hand either way. Neither did I have the right to.
I gathered my photographs and walked out past the coatrack.
Main Street was cold enough for my breath to show. The firehouse doors stood open with the bay lights on, and a young man in a rescue jacket was crouched beside the bumper of the ambulance, working a small screwdriver against the battery cap of a flashlight.
I stopped because the lost-kitten notice was still in my coat pocket and the firehouse corkboard was right there.
“Evening,” he said, standing up fast. “Arlen Brooks. Volunteer rescue. Are you needing something?”
“Just a posting.” I pinned the notice at eye level, a calico kitten, one white foot. “You are the one who works on the flashlights.”
“Somebody has to.” He clicked the cap back on and thumbed the switch. The beam threw a white circle against the brick wall so bright it hurt to look at. “Waterproof. Twelve hours on one charge. Two hundred feet of visibility in flood conditions.”
“That is a serious flashlight.”
“Not serious enough for some jobs.” He said it fast and then went quiet, and I understood that whatever job he meant had not gone well.
Above us a crow settled on the utility wire, and the streetlight caught something on its right ankle.
Arlen tilted his head back. “Will you look at that.”
“What?”
“Silver band on its leg. There is a number on it. You can read it when it turns.”
The bird turned. I read four characters out loud before it hopped along the wire.
“Four zero eight B.”
Arlen already had his phone out. “State wildlife studies band urban crows. That number goes in a database somewhere. My cousin Nadia works in that department at the university. She would know what to do with it.”
“I know a woman who needs a biologist more than a database,” I said.
“Then you want Nadia Okafor.” He said her name slowly so I could write it down. “She studies crow memory. Tracks individual birds for years. She will tell you more about that bird than you ever wanted to know.”
I wrote it on the back of a grocery receipt with a pencil stub from the corkboard. Then I walked home and sat on the edge of Birdie’s bed.
Her quilt was up to her chin and the pink butterfly clip was on the nightstand where she left it every night. One wing had a chip out of the corner.
“Edgar talked to me through the fence,” she said. “He said the kitten is cold.”
“Did he.”
“He said it three times.” She turned on her side. “Birds do not lie, Mom. It is not in their nature.”
I sat there a while after her breathing went slow. My printed photographs were in the wastebasket by the door, all four of them, face up.
I pulled them out and flattened the curl at one corner. Then I carried them to the kitchen and set them under the sugar bowl so they would not blow away.
The county recorder’s annex opened at nine. I intended to be standing at the counter when it did.
Dr. Nadia Okafor came up the flagstone path with binoculars on a strap and a tablet under one arm, and she stopped four feet short of the porch steps.
“Don’t look up fast,” she said. “He’s in the fork of the oak. A crow reads a quick head turn as a threat.”
I kept my chin down and looked at her instead. Torn pocket on her canvas jacket, tortoiseshell glasses pushed up into her hair.
“A young man from your firehouse called our office last night,” she said. “He read me a number off a silver band. I have been chasing that bird for two years.”
“408-B,” I said.
“You have it by heart.”
“Birdie wrote it on the kitchen calendar the night Arlen spotted it. She used a green marker and underlined it.”
Edgar came off the oak then, not so much flying as folding, and landed on the porch rail six feet from my boot. Nadia went still as furniture.
He cocked his head at her, hopped twice, and set something down on the wood.
A brass bottle cap, bright as a new penny, wet from wherever he’d found it.
“Is that for me?” Nadia asked.
“He brings Birdie things,” I said. “That’s the whole trouble I’m in.”
Nadia picked the cap up between two fingers and turned it toward the light. “He set it down nearer your boot than mine.”
Then she asked to see the gully.
I went inside, fished the printed photos out of the trash basket, and smoothed them flat on the dining table. She set her coffee down without drinking any of it.
“Fifty-four inches,” she said. “That’s a big pipe. How long is it?”
“Sixty feet, by the county sheet. It runs under County Road 14.”
She pulled out a notepad and drew a circle, then a smaller circle inside it, then a dot. “This is how they know you. Crows don’t just remember a face that fed them, Ms. Vance. They map the whole household. Your walk, your car, the child.”
“That’s a kind thing to hear,” I said. “It’s hard to say out loud at a board meeting.”
“Then I’ll say it at the board meeting.” She wrote Friday, five o’clock across the top of the page and underlined it twice.
“Five is when the lien files.”
“Then five is when I talk.” She turned the tablet around and showed me a column of dates. “Band 408-B came out of a batch our lab issued three years back. I sent the number to the federal banding office this morning. The record comes back tomorrow with the site on it.”
“Tomorrow.”
“Tomorrow.” She capped her pen. “One condition, and you won’t like it. Empty bowl until Friday night. Forty-eight hours, no peanuts, nothing on that rail.”
“Why?”
“Because his bylaw says attracting. If there’s food out there, Dennison is right and I’m just a bird lady with a grudge.”
I looked at the clock over the stove. Ten fifty-eight.
“Two days is a long time for a six-year-old,” I said.
“Two days is a long time for a crow, too. He’ll come anyway. That’s what I want on the record.”
The elementary school let out at eleven that week for conferences, so Birdie was home before Nadia’s car cleared the corner.
She came through the screen door with her backpack still on and stopped when she saw the porch rail bare of the ceramic bowl.
“Where are the peanuts?”
I sat down on the top step and pulled her down beside me. Nadia crouched on the flagstones so she’d be at eye level.
“Edgar has to go two days without them,” I said. “Wednesday and Thursday. Friday night the bowl comes back.”
Birdie’s chin went crooked. “Is he in trouble?”
“No. He’s not in trouble. I am.”
“Does he know we’re not mad?” she said. “Because if the bowl is empty he might think we moved away.”
Nadia answered that one. “He’ll know. He watches your face more than he watches the bowl.”
Birdie touched the pink butterfly clip above her left ear and turned it once, slow. “Two sleeps,” she said. “That’s how long Grandma’s vacation was.”
“Two sleeps,” I said.
“Then I promise.” She stuck out her hand, and Nadia shook it like a contract, and Birdie ran inside to put her backpack away.
Nadia stood and brushed off her knees. “Friday, five o’clock. I’ll bring the tablet and a printout of the literature. And Ms. Vance, if you have a piece of paper with his signature on it, bring that too.”
The county recorder’s annex downtown closed at four thirty, so I parked crooked and went in with my folder under my arm.
The clerk found the Sycamore Creek clubhouse file on microfilm and let me use the machine by the window. Third roll, second reel, page after page of vouchers.
The paving invoice sat four pages in. The approved amount was eight thousand one hundred dollars. The total at the bottom was ten thousand five hundred.
Twenty-four hundred over. A note in the margin, in fountain pen ink, said paid in full, April 18.
Three lines below that, on the same voucher: culvert grate, steel, fifty-four inch, deferred.
I copied it all onto the back of my grocery receipt and paid a dollar for the prints.
On the way out the clerk said, “You’re the third person this month to ask for that file.”
I stopped with my hand on the door. “Who were the other two?”
“One was a fellow with a clipboard. The other one didn’t leave a name.”
The sky over the canal ridge had gone the color of a dishpan by the time I turned onto Sycamore Lane.
The mailbox held a yellow envelope with the association’s return address and no stamp on it. Hand delivered, then. My name was on the front in fountain pen.
I had my thumb under the flap when Birdie called from the porch that she couldn’t find her other sneaker.
So I put the envelope in my cardigan pocket and went up the steps.
The ceramic bowl was still on the rail where I’d left it, dry, empty, a little grit in the bottom of it.
I picked it up in both hands and turned it over.
Edgar cawed once from the oak branch and flew toward the gully.
Walter’s car door shut beyond the oak tree, and I heard him call my name before I had carried the empty bowl inside.
I turned toward the porch steps.
“Clara, I have something for you.”
He came up the flagstone path carrying a white plate wrapped in aluminum foil. His gold-nibbed fountain pen was tucked into the pocket of his shirt.
“I thought we might have a civil conversation,” he said.
I set the bowl on the porch table.
“What sort of conversation?”
“The sort neighbors ought to have before matters get out of hand.”
He lifted the foil just enough to show me several lemon bars dusted with powdered sugar.
“I bought these at the bakery counter. Nothing fancy.”
“Thank you, Walter.”
He waited for me to take the plate. When I did, he glanced toward the front door.
“May I come in for a minute?”
I kept the plate in my hands.
“Is this about the fine?”
“It is about finding a reasonable way forward.”
He took a folded yellow sheet from his clipboard and held it out to me. I noticed that he had written my full address at the top, including the townhouse number.
“Four hundred and twelve Sycamore Lane,” he said. “I have tried to be fair with you.”
I read the first few lines. The association had agreed to reduce my three hundred dollar violation to one hundred and fifty dollars.
“That’s half.”
“Exactly. One hundred and fifty dollars, and we can put this unpleasant business behind us.”
He spoke softly, almost as though he were discussing a neighbor’s fence that needed painting.
I thought of the tax installment folded inside my desk drawer. One hundred and fifty dollars was still money I needed, but it was not three hundred.
“What do you want me to sign?”
“Just an acknowledgment that we have reached an agreement.”
He pointed to the bottom of the page.
“Nothing complicated, Clara. We all want neighborhood harmony.”
I looked at the blank signature line.
“Can I read the whole thing first?”
“Of course. That’s why I brought it.”
He stepped inside after I opened the screen door, and I carried the lemon bars into the living room.
Walter stopped beside Birdie’s little table.
The glass Mason jar stood there with its collection of gifts from Edgar. A bottle cap, a tarnished silver button, and the pearl earring rested at the bottom.
Walter bent down to look through the glass.
“Well, Bonnie has quite a collection.”
I looked at him.
“Her name is Birdie.”
“Yes, yes. Birdie.”
He straightened and glanced toward the back yard.
“She still keeps all these little objects?”
“She likes them.”
“Children can get attached to the strangest things.”
Birdie had once spent nearly twenty minutes explaining why a bottle cap was more valuable than a new toy. She said Edgar had chosen it, and that made it special.
Walter picked up the jar, examined the silver button, and set it back on the table.
“Does Bonnie ever take these outside?”
“Birdie,” I corrected him again.
He gave a small laugh.
“Of course. Birdie.”
His eyes moved toward the rear windows.
I followed his gaze. The back cedar gate was visible beyond the porch railing, its latch still showing the small repair I had made earlier in the week.
“That gate needs attention,” he said.
“I fixed the latch.”
“Perhaps not properly. I could send someone to look at it.”
“Why?”
“Just being helpful.”
He rubbed his thumb along the edge of the jar.
“That little opening underneath can invite all sorts of trouble.”
I took the jar from his hand.
“Birdie knows not to leave the yard without me.”
“Naturally.”
He looked toward the back yard once more before turning away from the window.
“Would you like to see the agreement now?”
I carried the yellow sheet to the kitchen counter.
Walter followed, uncapping his fountain pen as he walked.
“Here you are,” he said. “I brought my own pen so you wouldn’t have to search for one.”
I laid the paper flat and began reading.
The first paragraph identified the original seventy-five dollar violation. The second referred to the repeat offense and the three hundred dollar assessment. The third offered the reduced payment of one hundred and fifty dollars.
The fourth paragraph was longer.
I read it once, then again.
It said that by signing, I agreed not to request county inspections of any drainage easement maintained by the Sycamore Creek Homeowners Association.
I moved my finger beneath the sentence.
“What does this have to do with feeding a crow?”
Walter placed his pen beside the paper.
“It’s a standard provision.”
“It says I cannot request a county inspection.”
“It simply prevents unnecessary disputes over association property.”
“Why would paying a bird-feeding fine prevent me from calling a county inspector?”
He reached for the paper, but I kept my hand on its corner.
“Clara, there is no need to make this difficult.”
I turned the sheet over.
The date at the top of the final section was April 18.
I looked at it for several seconds.
“Why is this dated April eighteenth?”
“That was when the association prepared the agreement.”
“Today is Thursday.”
“I know what day it is.”
“Then why does a new settlement carry an April date?”
Walter uncapped his pen again.
“It was the date the original matter was entered into our records.”
I looked at the fountain pen.
The same gold nib had signed the April inspection sheet I had photographed in the clubhouse. I could still see his name at the bottom of that document on my phone.
“Did the board approve this?”
“The board authorized me to settle routine violations.”
“Did they authorize you to stop me from contacting county inspectors?”
He tapped the pen twice against the counter.
“You’re making a simple arrangement into something it isn’t.”
I turned the paper around and read paragraph four once more.
The restriction covered every drainage easement in Sycamore Creek, not just the one behind my house.
“Why does a bird-feeding agreement mention drainage easements?”
He did not answer.
My phone rang on the kitchen table.
Nadia’s name appeared on the screen.
I picked it up.
“Clara, I have the information on Edgar’s band.”
I glanced at Walter, who had lowered his pen.
“Tell me.”
“Four zero eight B was attached at the county reservoir three years ago. That’s about two miles from your property.”
I sat on the edge of the kitchen chair.
“So he came from the reservoir?”
“Yes. He was recorded there before he began appearing in your yard.”
Walter moved his hand toward the yellow paper.
Nadia continued.
“There’s another detail I wanted you to understand. Crows remember individual faces. They don’t forget a household simply because several seasons have passed.”
I looked through the kitchen doorway toward Birdie’s jar.
“Birdie thinks Edgar brings her presents.”
“That is not as strange as it sounds. He recognizes the people who have treated him kindly. He has learned your faces, too.”
“Thank you, Nadia.”
“Keep the records you photographed, Clara. And don’t let anyone tell you the band is meaningless.”
When I ended the call, Walter was studying the yellow waiver.
“Was that the wildlife woman?”
“Dr. Nadia Okafor.”
“She has been encouraging you?”
“She has been answering my questions.”
“Well, I hope she understands that the association has responsibilities.”
I put my phone beside the paper.
“She understands quite a bit about birds.”
Walter picked up his pen.
“Then perhaps she can explain why attracting them to a residential property is such a good idea.”
“She already has.”
He looked toward the living room again.
“Is Bonnie at school?”
“Birdie is at home with me.”
He nodded, but his eyes stayed on the rear window.
I folded my arms.
“Why do you keep looking out there?”
“I’m checking the gate. I told you I could arrange a repair.”
“I don’t need anyone to repair it.”
He slid the pen into his shirt pocket.
“Well, the offer stands.”
The foil-wrapped lemon bars sat untouched beside the kitchen sink. I had not even taken one out of the plate.
Walter returned to the yellow sheet.
“Clara, I am trying to save you money. One hundred and fifty dollars is a fair settlement.”
“Not if I have to give up my right to ask the county whether a drainage pipe is safe.”
He looked at me without speaking.
I pulled the paper closer.
“Does paragraph four apply to the County Road 14 culvert?”
His face changed very slightly.
“That culvert is maintained according to the association schedule.”
“That wasn’t my question.”
“The inspection was completed in April.”
“Then why do you need me to promise not to request another one?”
He reached across the counter and straightened the yellow sheet.
“Because repeated complaints cost the association money.”
I remembered the April ledger and the bare concrete opening beneath County Road 14. I remembered the rusted steel grate lying in the weeds.
“Did you personally inspect that culvert?”
Walter looked at the kitchen clock.
“I have already explained that the inspection was completed.”
“By whom?”
“The association maintains proper records.”
“Who signed them?”
His fingers stopped moving.
For a few seconds, the only sound was the refrigerator motor starting in the next room.
Then he picked up his pen.
“You’re making an unfortunate choice.”
I took the yellow waiver from beneath his hand and folded it once.
“Perhaps.”
He looked at the fold.
“You should think carefully about tomorrow.”
“I have been thinking about it.”
“The lien deadline is five o’clock Friday afternoon. The association attorney has instructions to file if the three hundred dollars remains unpaid.”
I looked at the calendar hanging beside the refrigerator.
Friday was circled in red.
“Five o’clock,” I said.
“That’s correct.”
“And the amount is three hundred dollars?”
“Unless you accept the settlement.”
I held up the folded waiver.
“One hundred and fifty dollars, in exchange for giving up my right to call county inspectors.”
He did not answer.
I walked him back through the living room. He paused beside Birdie’s jar again, then reached toward the glass.
I moved it out of his way.
“Careful,” I said. “She has everything arranged just the way she likes it.”
He gave me a thin smile.
“Of course.”
At the front door, I handed him the yellow waiver and the plate of lemon bars.
“Take these with you.”
“You haven’t even tried one.”
“I’ll save them for another day.”
He held the plate against his chest.
“Clara, I am giving you an opportunity to settle this quietly.”
“I heard you.”
“You may not get another.”
I pressed my thumb against the silver wedding band on my left hand.
“Then I suppose I will have to manage without one.”
For the first time since arriving, Walter stopped pretending to smile.
He stepped down from the porch and turned toward his car.
I watched him open the driver’s door.
“One more question, Walter.”
He looked back.
“Why did you call my daughter Bonnie?”
He stood beside the car with the plate still in his hands.
“I made a mistake.”
“You made it twice.”
He put the plate on the passenger seat.
“Children’s names can be difficult to keep straight when one has so many neighbors.”
“Birdie is six. She lives in this house. You have met her more than once.”
He closed the car door.
“I have a board meeting to prepare for.”
I stayed on the porch until he started the engine.
His taillights came on, and he backed away from the curb. Before turning toward the end of Sycamore Lane, he glanced once more at the rear of my house.
I went inside and put the lemon bars in the refrigerator.
The yellow waiver was no longer on my counter, but its fourth paragraph stayed in my mind.
I returned to my desk and opened the photographs from the clubhouse. The April inspection sheet showed Walter’s signature beneath the statement that the County Road 14 culvert had been inspected and secured with a locked steel grate.
I enlarged the photograph.
The date was April 18.
I opened the paving invoice beside it. The contractor’s charge showed an additional two thousand four hundred dollars.
I wrote both dates on a small piece of paper and placed it beneath my keyboard.
Then I opened the photograph of the culvert itself. The rusted grate was still lying beside the entrance, partly hidden by weeds.
A locked grate, according to Walter.
An unbolted grate, according to my photograph.
